Lead-Acid Vs Lithium-Ion Batteries. Is Lead Lifeless?

We reside in an age the place your camper trailer can energy an induction cooktop, a mine can go off-grid, and large grid-scale batteries are being introduced virtually weekly.

These developments in cell, distant space and utility-scale power storage could be impractical or not possible with lead-acid batteries. The efficiency of lithium-ion batteries has eclipsed the 100-year-old lead-acid expertise.

Many trade people will let you know “lead is useless”. However like several well-proven expertise, individuals belief it, and warrant it. In some purposes, like an electrical forklift, the load is definitely helpful.

Why Lithium-Ion Batteries Normally Win

1. Smaller measurement and better power density imply you’ll be able to retailer extra power in much less area.
2. Lighter weight means transport, logistics, and dealing with them is simpler.
3. The round-trip effectivity is absolutely good. 95% of the power you place in could be drawn again out.
4. Whereas they could nonetheless be costlier upfront, when you think about the cycle life they readily grow to be cheaper as a result of they’re warranted to last more.
5. They are often pushed a lot tougher: charged sooner, discharged sooner and routinely labored to a lot deeper states of discharge. So for a similar nominal kilowatt-hour capability, you will get extra out of a lithium battery. This implies you will get away with shopping for a smaller one within the first place.

Lead-Acid Requires TLC

Lead-acid likes to work within the high 20% of its state of cost. They’ll deal with 30 or 40%, however the deeper you discharge the shorter their life is. In the event you take 60% out of them it’s thought of an emergency.

Whereas you’ll be able to fortunately run 80% out of a lithium-ion battery and quickly cost it again as much as 100% the subsequent morning with a giant photo voltaic panel array.

Picture credit score: Clear Vitality Opinions

Conversely, charging lead acid batteries is like steering a ship. You want time to get them headed in the precise path. Thrash about an excessive amount of and Peukert’s exponent will rob you of nice wads of effectivity.

Lead-acid likes to be cared for, with currents saved modest and sustained equalisation fees to stability them up each fortnight. They’ll reward you with 20 years of life in the event you do. Actually, I’ve a set of geriatric flooded cells from a Telstra cellphone alternate that, regardless of a number of failures, are nonetheless effervescent away quietly at 30+ years.

Wherever you discover flooded cells, there will likely be bottles for topping up water.

seventeenth July 1991. I’ve by no means been positive if that’s a producing date or a take a look at completed by Telstra for a upkeep program. At 30+ years and their third deployment, there’s nonetheless sufficient to run the fridge over Easter.

Put merely, lead-acid ought to be cycled within the high 20% of its capability ideally. A nominal 10 kWh of storage could be completely satisfied to supply 2 kWh of saved power each day. A lithium-ion battery of the identical score would fortunately return 80% of its capability, so you can get 8 kWh of storage.

Lithium-Ion Battery Packs Are Simple To Scale

The opposite incomparable characteristic of lithium is that they typically are available in self-contained slabs of nominal kilowatt-hour capability. This implies you should buy two or three batteries with, say, 3 kWh of storage every. In the event that they show inadequate over winter otherwise you discover your consumption grows, you’ll be able to simply add extra batteries later.

Lead acid banks are available in no matter measurement you order, and growing capability means both you purchase one other full set to double up, or promote them and purchase totally different ones.

In both case, mixing any batteries of significantly totally different ages isn’t actually smart, however lead acid might be worse affected.

However… Lead Acid Is Not Lifeless But

Except for being completely understood with 100 years of confirmed historical past, maybe the principal benefit lead-acid has is that they’re 100% recyclable. I feel every little thing bar the sticker on the entrance could be made into a brand new battery, and we have already got all of the expertise and infrastructure in place to shut the loop on manufacturing.

The scrap worth of lead means individuals will do the work concerned in taking them away without cost. My former auto electrical employer discovered they’ll elevate them over a series mesh fence on the weekend when you’re not watching. These had been hard-working thieves.

And whereas I don’t like to have interaction in hyperbole, lead acid doesn’t burst into spectacular self-sustaining incendiaries.

Previous flooded lead acid cells could make hydrogen, which is explosive, however they’ve by no means wanted a fancy layer of electronics to maintain them in a goldilocks zone of temperature and cost. Lead has most well-liked situations, however simply isn’t as outright fussy.

My intestine feeling is lead can have a task in modest stationary purposes sooner or later.

Lithium-ion is nice in automobiles and telephones however I feel it’s wasteful in, for example, electrical window shutters (cheaper than an electrician putting in wiring, paradoxically).

It was solely a few years in the past I used to be concerned in taking 8 tons of result in Innaminka to repower the RFDS clinic there. Utilizing lead carbon, a more moderen and better-performing lead-acid expertise, was cheaper; they usually’re not going anyplace quickly.

With nice energy comes the heavy burden of duty. Dealing with a tonne of lead, the trailer wheel bearing couldn’t bear it after 900km.

Lithium EV Batteries Can Get A Second Life

Electrical automobiles are actually onerous on batteries – you really want gentle weight and excessive efficiency to satisfy individuals’s ludicrous expectations of what a automobile ought to do. As they age and efficiency degrades, you’ll finally discover your EV doesn’t go as far, as quick, for as lengthy. The troglodytes like to level this out as a failure of electrical automobiles with out understanding you’ll be able to already double the vary of a 10-year-old Mitsubishi i-Miev with a brand new battery.

The very best half is the outdated pack has a salvage worth, as a result of “low efficiency” EV batteries are nonetheless completely viable for much less demanding purposes such house battery storage or avenue lights. Nissan and BMW each provide ‘second-life’ lithium-ion batteries as house storage, the place the much less strenuous cost and discharge cycles imply ageing batteries are much less of an issue.

What About Recycling?

The Chinese language battery trade and Tesla are pursuing used batteries, as a result of they’re high-grade ore to make new batteries.

Lithium batteries usually include high-grade copper and aluminium along with – relying on the chemistry – cobalt and nickel, in addition to uncommon earths. Processes are being developed to get better not solely cobalt, nickel, copper, and aluminium from spent battery cells, but in addition a major share of lithium, graphite and manganese. Recycling processes get better 25% to 96% of the supplies of a lithium-ion battery cell, relying on the separation expertise.

In keeping with latest reviews, China has even been shopping for used EV batteries from abroad. Bao Wei, the overall supervisor of Jiangsu Huayou, a recycling unit of Zhejiang Huayou Cobalt, stated at a discussion board in Nanjing the now tens of millions of EVs on the roads globally are properly described as “transferring steel mines.” At the least your automobile battery gained’t be as simple to steal as a catalytic converter.

It’s an idea Elon Musk touched on too at a Tesla annual common assembly, saying you’ll be able to consider batteries as:

“primarily high-grade ore … So you’ll be able to both get your lithium and your nickel and the varied constituents of the battery from rocks, or from batteries. It’s significantly better to get them from batteries,”

Spending My Personal Cash

I haven’t settled on what to make use of at my home but. Occurring the shortage of brown paper envelopes I’ve acquired from photo voltaic battery producers¹, it might simply be second-hand Sonnenscheins salvaged from a drained outdated off-grid system.

No actually, I’ve bought a tonne of lead, a hand truck and a masochistic streak.

Associated